The stance up front: 'Pinocchio: Unstrung' is the first Twisted Childhood Universe film worth your full ticket price, and it isn't close. Scream Scale: 9.1.
The scoreboard. Rotten Tomatoes: 75% from 20 critics — after debuting at a flawless 100% across the first ten, the first Fresh in the five-film Poohniverse. Audience Popcornmeter: 67%. IMDb: 6.0. That critic-audience gap tells you the reviews are responding to craft, not hype — and the craft is the story here.
The case for the score. One: the creature. Pinocchio is a practical animatronic built under Emmy-winner Todd Masters ('Child's Play' 2019), and it changes the movie's physics — every kill is staged against a thing that actually exists. Variety called the film "something of a triumph for the film's puppetry and animatronic departments" and, on the gore ledger, "abundantly gross and grisly in all the ways a cheap-and-cheerful slasher should be." Two: the villain voice. Robert Englund's Cricket is a franchise-best performance — The Cosmic Circus flagged him "channeling the sadistic delivery of Freddy Krueger while simultaneously making Cricket feel like an entity all his own." Three: it finishes. Scare Value: "An earned ending focused on what makes this version of Pinocchio so interesting keeps you engaged until the credits roll."
The fine print. Box office opened quiet — $295,731 from 505 theaters per Box Office Mojo — which makes this the definition of a see-it-before-everyone-claims-they-always-loved-it picture. The lean 82-minute runtime is a feature, not a bug: zero filler, all kill. The 0.9 we withhold is purely so the crossover has something to beat.
The verdict. Variety's closer on director Rhys Frake-Waterfield is the line of the cycle: "As B-horror auteurs go, he may yet be a real boy." We concur. The Poohniverse spent four films as a punchline; this one is a movie. With 'Poohniverse: Monsters Assemble' in pre-production, 'Unstrung' just raised the bar the crossover has to clear. R-rated, in theaters now — see it before the stream.
Comments (34)